Cherry Pie | Cookies & Cups

What Makes This the Greatest Cherry Pie Recipe

• Simple to make. I make this pie from scratch with my simple 10-minute cherry pie filling and a buttery selfmade crust. Each are easy recipes, however you possibly can at all times substitute your favourite store-bought variations for those who’re pressed for time.
• Thick and sliceable. After many rounds of testing, I’ve lastly cracked the key to thick slices of pie that maintain within the filling. No runny cherry pie right here! It comes right down to simmering the cherries lengthy sufficient and giving the pie loads of time to set.
• Excellent for any season. Cherry pie is the right strategy to take advantage of in-season fruit. The filling seems finest once I make it with ripe, candy darkish cherries. That being stated, you may make this pie year-round with frozen cherries, too.

Elements You’ll Want

You actually solely want a handful of elements to make an ideal cherry pie. Even my crust recipe makes use of pantry staples that you just doubtless have available. See my notes beneath. I’ve linked to the crust and filling recipes within the recipe card, the place you’ll additionally discover the elements checklist for this pie with particular quantities.

Simple Selfmade Cherry Pie Filling

Whereas canned filling will produce a wonderfully acceptable cherry pie, for those who ask me, nothing compares to the style and thickness of selfmade cherry pie filling. It’s as simple as tossing contemporary or frozen cherries with water, sugar, lemon juice, and cornstarch after which simmering every part on the stovetop for 10 minutes. It shops within the fridge for days, and you need to use the leftovers as a topping for cheesecake!

Tips on how to Make Cherry Pie

The pie crust and cherry pie filling every take about 10 minutes to make (I’ll normally get the filling simmering on the range whereas I make the pie dough). As soon as your pie filling and dough are prepared, observe the steps beneath. You’ll discover the printable directions within the recipe card.

• Put together the pie crust. Begin by flouring your work floor and rolling out one half of the pie dough right into a 12-inch circle. Afterward, gently press the crust right into a 9-inch pie plate.

• Add the filling. Subsequent, unfold the cherry pie filling into the crust. Dot the highest of the filling with cubes of butter.
• Add a prime crust. Now, place the highest crust over the pie and fold and crimp the sides. You are able to do a lattice crust just like the one pictured (I embrace an in-depth tutorial on how one can make a lattice pie crust in my apple pie recipe, for these ). In any other case, for those who maintain it easy with a stable crust, keep in mind to chop 4-6 vent holes within the prime to permit the steam to flee.

• Add an egg wash. Whichever prime crust fashion you select, end it with an egg wash. Beat an egg with water and a pinch of salt, and brush the combination all around the crust. Afterward, add a sprinkle of coarse sugar.
• Bake. Lastly, place the cherry pie on a baking sheet, and pop that right into a preheated oven to bake at 375ºF for 50-55 minutes. The filling ought to bubble for at the very least a couple of minutes earlier than the pie comes out of the oven, and the crust ought to be golden brown.
• Cool. The important thing to a wonderfully sliceable cherry pie is ample cooling time, so be sure that to price range at the very least 4 hours for this pie to chill. I even wish to bake the pie as much as sooner or later forward of serving and let it set in a single day.

Make It Forward

I’ll typically bake two cherry pies, one to get pleasure from now and one to freeze for later. This pie freezes nicely earlier than or after baking (see the storage ideas beneath on how one can freeze the baked model). To freeze the unbaked cherry pie, put together the pie as directed and wrap it tightly in plastic wrap, then in foil. Hold it frozen for as much as 1 month. When it’s time to bake, unwrap the pie and bake it straight from frozen with 10-Quarter-hour added to the baking time.

Recipe Ideas

• Prepare dinner the filling. It’s vital to simmer contemporary cherries for the filling to keep away from a soggy cherry pie. Pre-cooking the filling additionally prevents a cavity from forming underneath the highest crust, which occurs when contemporary, raw cherries shrink as they bake. This doesn’t apply for those who’re utilizing a ready-to-use cherry pie filling from the shop.
• Keep away from burnt edges. I recommend checking the pie after 25 minutes. Should you discover the crust is browning shortly, cowl the sides with a pie protect or aluminum foil to stop them from burning whereas the pie finishes baking.
• Cool the pie fully. Should you slice into selfmade cherry pie whereas it’s nonetheless heat (as tempting because it is perhaps), you’ll find yourself with soupy slices that will disintegrate. Because of this, I like to recommend giving this pie 4 hours or extra to chill and set earlier than slicing. It’s the key to thick, picture-perfect slices.

Tips on how to Retailer

• At room temperature. Retailer the cherry pie for as much as 2 days at room temperature. Hold it frivolously coated in order that the crust doesn’t develop into soggy.
• Refrigerate. For longer storage, you possibly can maintain the coated pie within the fridge for as much as 5 days.
• Freeze. As soon as the baked pie has cooled fully, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and a second layer of foil, and freeze it for as much as 1 month. Thaw the pie, unwrapped, at room temperature.